Home Boating & Fishing Feds Decide: Is 2017 Fluke Season ‘Dead’ in New Jersey?

Feds Decide: Is 2017 Fluke Season ‘Dead’ in New Jersey?

An angler shows off his fluke caught in Barnegat Bay. (Photo: Jersey Shore Fishing Magazine)
An angler shows off his fluke caught in Barnegat Bay. (Photo: Jersey Shore Fishing Magazine)

A federal panel this week decided to slash the summer flounder quota between 28 and 32 percent in New Jersey, leading some to wonder if the measure will all but destroy the state’s recreational fishing industry in New Jersey.

The Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission met in Alexandria, Va., this week to decide on five options – all of which would slash the recreational quota for summer flounder, also known as fluke. Experts estimate the minimum size for a legal fluke this year will be a 19-inches with a low bag limit of about three fish. In 2016 New Jersey anglers held a 5 fish bag limit with an 18 inch minimum requirement.

The decision sent shockwaves through the New Jersey recreational fishing community, including government officials who attended the meeting and attempted to delay the vote. Adam Nowalsky, one of the state’s representatives on the board, told the Asbury Park Press following the 7-2 vote: “Our industry is just killed.”


The sharp reduction in quota is linked to federal data that shows low recruitment – new fish entering the ecosystem to replace older fish that die or are harvested for food. But other studies have shown the data is severely flawed and populations are among the healthiest they have been since records have been kept.

If New Jersey officials refuse to accept the federal decision, a blanket regulation of a 20-inch minimum and two month-long season takes effect.

The state’s Department of Environmental Protection commissioner and congressional delegation are reportedly working on ways to reverse the decision, including a potential appeal to President Donald Trump to stop “regulation for regulation’s sake,” said James Donofrio, founder of the Recreational Fishing Alliance, a national fishing advocacy group based in New Jersey.

“We are outraged by the summer flounder quota reductions approved today by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission and National Marine Fisheries Service,” DEP Commissioner Bob Martin said in a statement to Shorebeat. “Today’s actions will disproportionately impact New Jersey more than any other state along the coast.”

“We will use every legal and administrative tool available to stop these unfair cuts that will devastate our state’s fishing industry and have far-reaching impacts on the shore economy,” Martin continued. “We will work to ensure that sound science replaces the current outdated, whipsaw form of management that has harmed our fishing communities for far too long.”

“Just when our fishing industry was recovering from the devastation of Hurricane Sandy, unelected bureaucrats in Washington use questionable methodologies and outdated science to cut us off at the knees,” said U.S. Rep. Frank LoBiondo (R). “I will do everything in my power to run this ASMFC decision aground.”

  • craigoftruth

    The same people who over fished the area are now crying? Either you fish today and never fish again or you wait for the population to rebound so you can fish tomorrow. Here all of this time I thought fisherpeople were smart.

    • J W

      American greedocracy. I want mine at all costs, never mind that I’ll be putting myself and kids out of work.

  • Cullen McAskill

    I’m a student writing an article about this and it’s not actually feds who decide the catch limits. ASMFC gives a total catch for the whole Atlantic region and then delegates tonnage of fish for the year between states but it’s the state of NJ who decided on the 19” and 3 bag limit which ASMFC ultimately approved and published. They did this in response to not only NJ’s fishery’s poor performance scores since 2014 but also the unique demand for summer flounder by NJ fisherman which is not seen in other states. I’m unsure of the “[not] sound” “and “outdated” method of data capture employed by ASMFC and NMFS the folks cited here are talking about. If anything, these methods could be improved by incorporating discarded flounder to the tonnage of fish caught per year which implies that the per capita catch rate is too low. (sources: https://static1.squarespace.com/static/511cdc7fe4b00307a2628ac6/t/5845dce96b8f5bb337d9f23f/1480973549446/Tab+12_Summer+Flounder+Allocation.pdf

    http://www.asmfc.org/uploads/file/56d77016SFlounder_BSB_AddendumXXVII_Feb2016.pdf )

  • Angelo G

    Stop the commercial fishing and it will come back in two years like never before.
    They are killing our fishery.

  • RJ

    commercial fishing industry accounts for 97% of harvesting! Why didn’t they get hit with new regulations? MONEY, PAYOLA and all that goes on!