Home Boating & Fishing N.J. Fluke Season Will Begin Thursday As Planned

N.J. Fluke Season Will Begin Thursday As Planned

Grandpa Denny and Grandson Ryan on board the Cock Robin party boat out of Point Pleasant Beach this week. The pair nabbed four keeper fluke! (Photo: Cock Robin Crew)
Grandpa Denny and Grandson Ryan on board the Cock Robin party boat out of Point Pleasant Beach this week. The pair nabbed four keeper fluke! (Photo: Cock Robin Crew)

Despite the rejection of New Jersey’s 2017 fluke fishing regulations by a federal board, the season will open Thursday as planned, inclusive of the size limit decided upon by the state Marine Fisheries Council.

The Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission rejected the state’s adopted regulations: a season running May 25 through Sept. 5, during which time anglers can keep three fish per day and 18-inches or more. The ASFMC proposed regulations that would have likely raised the legal size of a keeper fluke to 19-inches.

The state has said it wants to protect its multi billion-dollar fishing and boating industry, as well as the fishery. Had the proposed federal regulations been adopted, more fish would have died from being thrown back in the water than from being taken for the kitchen table. Additionally, researchers have found that fish larger than 18-inches are almost always female, cautioning that targeting just one gender of fish for harvest could be detrimental. New Jersey DEP Commission Bob Martin said the 18-inch limit, with a low bag limit and short season, was effectively equivalent to the federal government’s call for a 19-inch size limit with a longer season.


“We are going forward with the regulations because we strongly believe that we have passed regulations that meet the conservation equivalency of the commission’s proposed quota limits,” Martin said. “We have a good relationship with NOAA fisheries and will continue to work with them on any issues relating to the summer flounder stock and recreational harvest limit.”

Despite a motion by the ASMFC’s Summer Flounder Management Board on Monday to not accept New Jersey’s new rules, the state’s summer flounder season will remain as scheduled. Any possible federal non-compliance decisions would first need to be voted on by ASFMC’s Policy Board and the full Commission before a finding of non-compliance is sent to NOAA Marine Fisheries for consideration.

Politically, fishing advocates believe President Donald Trump’s appointees to the Department of Commerce, which oversees NOAA Fisheries, will be more sympathetic to anglers than those appointed during the two terms of President Barack Obama. It was expected from the beginning that the ASMFC would find New Jersey out of compliance, sources said.

“We remain disappointed that the commission’s Summer Flounder Management Board advocates for a quota limit that kills more fish through dead discards than the actual harvesting of fluke,” Martin said in a statement. “We look forward to working with NOAA Fisheries to bring logic and reason to the implementation of sound fishery management in New Jersey, which will help protect the stock without devastating a multi-billion dollar industry here in the state.”

The minimum size limit this season will remain 17 inches for Delaware Bay. Each angler may keep three legally sized fish caught from the bay each day. The Shore-Based Enhanced Fishing Opportunity Program at Island Beach State Park in Ocean County will continue with a 16-inch size limit and two-fish per day, per person possession limit. This program was set up to assist the Division of Fish and Wildlife in its summer flounder research efforts.

  • Surfrider

    It is all a bunch of crap! Until they hone in on the commercial netters who take in tons of fish next to where recreational fisherman fish, that is where the issues are. 19″ is a tough length to catch, take it from someone known as the “fluke whisperer”. I have lots of friends who go often, and these new regulations stink and are not based on any plausible data. It certainly does not coincide with facts that a lot of us share with each other? 3 fluke 19″….C’mon. Might as well be 1 winter flounder, who is going to bother any more, these people are killing the sport and bringing nice filets to the dinner table!

    • Late Night Comedian

      Went fluking 2 years ago manasquan river. Caught about 40 fluke. No keepers. I guess about 5-10 died after being unhooked and thrown back.

  • Late Night Comedian

    How many undersized fluke die every day by the stress of catching them, removing the hook and then releasing?
    If the hook is well inside the fish, removal will almost always kill the fish.
    What a waste.
    The size limit should be in between range of about 12″ – 17″ limit of 3.
    This would protect small fish and the large breeder fish.

  • Surfrider

    Good idea! I agree. Very seldom can a small fish in 12 14 size range live if the hook is down. Lips are usually no issue, unless someone reels too fast and gives the fish the benz !